国产精品美女一区二区三区-国产精品美女自在线观看免费-国产精品秘麻豆果-国产精品秘麻豆免费版-国产精品秘麻豆免费版下载-国产精品秘入口

Set as Homepage - Add to Favorites

【?? ?? ??】Please stop arguing about the politics of safety pins

Source:Global Hot Topic Analysis Editor:synthesize Time:2025-07-03 03:16:44

The ?? ?? ??KKK-endorsed president-elect of the United States just appointed a white nationalist to his cabinet and has promised to deport or incarcerate two to three million undocumented immigrants as soon as he's inaugurated, but here's what the left is arguing about: safety pins.

After Trump was elected president last week and hate crimes began to spike, some began to wear safety pins to signal that people facing violence could reach out to them. It was a well-intentioned, simple gesture -- but over the weekend, some liberals and lefties began to furiously debate whether safety pins caused more damage than they prevented.

SEE ALSO: Here's a small way to support the vulnerable in Trump's America

On Saturday, Christopher Keelty over at The Huffington Post published an article that's since been liked over 140,000 times shares called, "Dear White People, your safety pins are embarrassing." In it, Keelty argues that white people who wear safety pins are doing little more than showing off their allyship, and doing absolutely nothing to help:

"And make no mistake, that’s what the safety pins are for. Making white people feel better," Keelty writes. "They’ll do little or nothing to reassure the marginalized populations they are allegedly there to reassure; marginalized people know full well the long history of white people calling themselves allies while doing nothing to help, or even inflicting harm on, non-white Americans."

The author then goes onto even compare people who wear safety pins to 18th century slave-owners, who were also motivated by notions of freedom and inequality:

"Remember the white guys in the 1770s who wrote all about freedom and equality and inalienable rights? Remember how they owned and sold slaves? Yeah, if that’s the spirit you want to evoke, go ahead and wear your safety pin," Keelty explains.

It is truly mind-blowing to imagine that a piece that compares people who wear safety pins to people who owned slaves, was published on a mainstream media publication, forget liked 140,000 times.

Alas, here we are in Trump's America -- and this is what we're fighting about.

Mashable Trend Report Decode what’s viral, what’s next, and what it all means. Sign up for Mashable’s weekly Trend Report newsletter. By clicking Sign Me Up, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Thanks for signing up!

Keelty's argument is based on multiple flawed premises that make for an even faultier -- though highly sharable -- analysis. First, he founds his entire argument on the idea that the only people wearing safety pins are white people. I, for one, would love to hear where he is getting this data, and who is even bothering to collect it. Both the ACLU and Southern Poverty Law Center, which documents hate crimes, changed their profile pictures to include safety pins -- are they just performative allies as well?

The author further argues white people wearing the safety pins will do nothing to help "immigrants, people of color, LGBTQ people and others who were targeted and persecuted and (further) marginalized by the Trump Campaign" -- while seemingly unaware that white people include people with disabilities, trans people, queer people and immigrants. Are there only certain kinds of white people who should be allowed to wear safety pins? Are trans and queer white people allowed to wear safety pins, but not cis? Should white people with disabilities stop wearing pins? What is this argument? And how are we actually having it at this historical moment in time?

I can't speak for the experiences of others. I'm white, and I certainly can't speak for the experiences of people of color -- though the reaction on social media from activists in the community appear to be mixed. But as a queer person who is frequently mistaken for a boy, and a journalist who has spent the last 48 hours reading about recent hate crimes against the LGBTQ community, I know I'd be happy to see someone with a safety pin traveling the subway or riding the Greyhound with me -- regardless of how effective they'd be at intervening. Other queer people might disagree with me, and that's totally okay too.

For Keelty, wearing safety pins is the ultimate symbol of apathy -- branding your allyship, instead of doing anything to actually change systems and structures. It's a very fair point, but it again resides on an enormous assumption: that the people wearing these safety pins aren't actually doing anything outside of them to enact social change. Who is to say that the people who are wearing pins or posting post-it notes aren't also donating to Planned Parenthood, attending a Black Lives Matter protest, and trying to organize to get progressives elected at a state level?

Of course, everyone needs to do more than wear a pin or post a note of hope. I strongly implore people currently wearing their safety pins to do more, if they aren't already -- donate more, make more calls, attend more organizing meetings, something. But that doesn't mean we should shame and attack people who are trying to do something within the first week of a crisis, especially when millions of Americans didn't even bother to show up at the polls this election, and millions more want a very different kind of "something" for their country.

When I was an organizer and social worker, we were taught to invite people in to activism, then encourage them to do more. Want to wear a safety pin? That's awesome, also consider donating to these organizations. Interested in sharing a hopeful post-it note on a subway wall? That's wonderful! We'd love to see you at this organizing meeting, too.

There are several good, understandable reasons not to wear safety pins: if, for example, the pins are adopted by white nationalists and hate groups on the right, and used to deceive people. Or if some people choose to misuse their pins to express their silent support instead of their out-loud advocacy.

Of course, everyone needs to do more than wear a pin or post a note of hope -- but that doesn't mean we should shame and attack people who are trying to do something

So if people want to wear safety pins, great! If they don't, that's also fine. Let's be honest: who cares.What's important to remember is this is such a small part of a terrifyingly large conversation. When I visited my Facebook this weekend, I saw so many people sharing links to Keelty's post and debating the value of the safety pins -- but not actually sharing resources about where to volunteer, donate and organize (like this one).

However you feel about safety pins -- and there are very legitimate reasons to dislike them -- extensive dialogues aboutthem are a depleting, predictably Facebook-esque waste of time and energy -- energy we need to preserve if we have any hope of moving forward.

I understand that by writing an anti-anti-safety-pins post, I've invited backlash, continued the conversation and possibly, the problem. Consider this a desperate plea, then, for those opposed to the Trump regime to not try and ignore these concerns but instead focus on bigger issues and larger problems, so that pieces like the one I just wrote won't have to be written anymore.


Featured Video For You
Watch this little girl bravely share her truth at an anti-Trump rally

0.1691s , 9867.3671875 kb

Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【?? ?? ??】Please stop arguing about the politics of safety pins,Global Hot Topic Analysis  

Sitemap

Top 主站蜘蛛池模板: 91香蕉视频在 | 91精产国品一二三产区公司 | 91大神国内精品免费观看 | av天堂中av世界中文在线 | av免费不卡在线 | 午夜福利久久久噜久噜久久综合 | 一区二区三区精品免费视频 | 国产不卡高清 | 99久久无码一区人妻A黑国产馆 | 国产91在线播放边 | 午夜精品成人免费 | 99je全部都是精品视频在线 | 91麻豆国产精品免费视频 | 午夜久久久久久禁播电影 | 99精品这里只有精品观看视频 | 91精品一区二 | 成电影人免费网站 | 99精品国产福利在线观看 | 果冻传媒91制片潘甜甜七夕年代穿越 | 91麻豆精品久久久久蜜臀 | 波多野办公室激情A片 | 韩国三日本三级中文字幕 | 国产v片精品在线播放 | av夜夜躁狠 | 午夜精品蜜臀一区二区三区免费 | 99久久国产综合精品女图图等你 | 91成人午夜在线精品 | 福利一区二区三区微拍视频 | 丰满少妇性开放视频 | 午夜福利高清无码在线观看 | 91精品国产福利在线观看麻豆 | 91精品人妻一区二区 | av中文字幕在线观 | 丰满熟妇啪啪 | 91噜噜噜在线观看 | 91久久人爽人人添人人澡 | 国产v亚洲v | 精品久久久久久久久久 | 91麻豆国产语对白在线观看 | 午夜福利免费在线观看 | www亚洲无码免费看 www亚洲无码在线观看 |